Fourth Circuit Lowers the Proof Standard for Green Cards in Immigration Court: What Nivar Santana v. Blanche Means for I-9 Citizenship Claims and Colorado Employers

Fourth Circuit Lowers the Proof Standard for Green Cards in Immigration Court: What Nivar Santana v. Blanche Means for I-9 Citizenship Claims and Colorado Employers

What the Fourth Circuit decided

On November 2, 2026, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit issued a published opinion in Sintia Dines Nivar Santana v. Blanche, No. 22-2114. Judge Thacker wrote the opinion, joined by Judges King and Heytens. The unanimous panel held that a noncitizen who was previously inspected and admitted, and who seeks adjustment of status as relief from removal, must prove admissibility by a preponderance of the evidence, not “clearly and beyond doubt.” The court granted Santana’s petition for review and remanded the case. It did not grant her a green card.

The dispute arose from a Form I-9 citizenship claim. Santana entered with her minor son on B-1/B-2 visitor visas in 2000 and remained past the expiration of those visas. Her son later naturalized through honorable U.S. Army service and filed a Form I-130 for her. USCIS denied her adjustment application in March 2016 after finding that she had falsely claimed U.S. citizenship by checking the citizenship box on an employment eligibility form for a 2013 job with an elder-care provider in Connecticut. In January 2017, USCIS served her with a notice to appear charging removability for overstaying her visa under 8 U.S.C. § 1227(a)(1)(B), and she conceded removability before the immigration judge in 2018, then renewed her adjustment application based on the approved Form I-130.

At her immigration hearing, Santana testified that she completed only the top part of the form and did not remember checking that box. An employer administrator testified that she recognized handwriting on the form belonging to herself and to her supervisor, that she believed the supervisor probably placed the checkmark, and that Santana had told her plainly that she was not a citizen. The supervisor submitted a letter denying that she checked the box. The immigration judge found the evidence inconclusive. Applying the higher standard, the judge denied relief because Santana had not proved clearly and beyond doubt that she was admissible.

The Fourth Circuit held that this was the wrong standard for a previously admitted adjustment applicant seeking relief in removal proceedings. Read the published opinion.

Why the court changed the proof standard

The court relied on the distinction between a person seeking admission to the United States and a person who was already admitted and is seeking adjustment of status from within the country.

Under 8 U.S.C. § 1229a(c)(2)(A), an “applicant for admission” must prove that they are “clearly and beyond doubt entitled to be admitted and are not inadmissible.” But 8 U.S.C. § 1225(a)(1) defines applicants for admission as people present in the United States who have not been admitted, or people who arrive in the United States. The Fourth Circuit concluded that a previously admitted adjustment applicant fits neither category.

Instead, the court applied the general rule for relief from removal in 8 C.F.R. § 1240.8(d): a respondent must establish eligibility for relief and prove by a preponderance of the evidence that grounds for mandatory denial do not apply. The court’s analysis also relied on 8 U.S.C. §§ 1255(a), 1101(a)(4), and 1101(a)(13)(A).

The case returned to the Fourth Circuit after the Supreme Court vacated its earlier decision and remanded it for reconsideration in light of Loper Bright Enterprises v. Raimondo, 603 U.S. 369 (2024). See Santana v. Garland, 145 S. Ct. 1042 (2025). On remand, the court rejected the government’s argument that Dakura v. Holder, 772 F.3d 994 (4th Cir. 2014), required the higher burden. It held that Dakura’s statement about the burden of proof was non-binding dicta.

Illustration of a stylized U.S. map with one eastern region highlighted and a gavel

The decision’s limits, and its significance in Colorado

The ruling binds courts in the Fourth Circuit: Maryland, North Carolina, South Carolina, Virginia, and West Virginia. It does not bind Colorado, which is in the Tenth Circuit. For Colorado cases, Nivar Santana may be persuasive, but absent a change from the Board of Immigration Appeals (BIA) or the Tenth Circuit, the BIA’s stricter framework under Matter of Bett, 26 I&N Dec. 437 (BIA 2014), continues to govern.

The BIA has not withdrawn Bett. The government may also seek panel rehearing or rehearing en banc. Readers should verify the case’s current status before relying on it.

The opinion addresses only previously admitted adjustment applicants seeking relief in removal proceedings. It does not address people who were never admitted, and it does not change the “clearly and beyond doubt” standard for arriving noncitizens or people present without admission or parole under 8 C.F.R. § 1240.8(b)–(c). It changes the proof standard for one category of applicants; it does not change the substantive grounds of inadmissibility.

Why a Form I-9 can affect a green card case

The alleged false claim in Nivar Santana involved Form I-9. Under INA § 212(a)(6)(C)(ii), codified at 8 U.S.C. § 1182(a)(6)(C)(ii), a noncitizen may be inadmissible for falsely representing themselves as a U.S. citizen for a purpose or benefit under the INA, including employment verification, or under another federal or state law. A parallel provision, INA § 237(a)(3)(D), codified at 8 U.S.C. § 1227(a)(3)(D), makes covered false claims a ground of deportability for a person who has already been admitted.

The Board of Immigration Appeals has held that a Form I-9 is admissible in immigration proceedings to support charges of removability and to determine eligibility for relief from removal, even where the person checked a citizenship or nationality box on the form. See Matter of Bett, 26 I&N Dec. 437 (BIA 2014), and Downs v. Holder, 758 F.3d 994 (8th Cir. 2014). The Board also treated a citizenship claim made on the form to obtain employment as conduct that can fall within the false-claim provisions. See also Hashmi v. Mukasey, 533 F.3d 700 (8th Cir. 2008). Confidentiality expectations about onboarding paperwork do not shield a Form I-9 from immigration authorities.

USCIS guidance and Matter of Zhang, 27 I&N Dec. 569 (BIA 2019), state that the statute does not require a false claim to be knowingly, intentionally, or willfully made. USCIS guidance also addresses whether the person had a subjective intent to obtain a purpose or benefit and whether citizenship affected or mattered to that purpose or benefit. It says age or mental capacity alone does not create an exception, although those factors may be relevant to the intent inquiry. See the USCIS Policy Manual, Volume 8, Part K, Chapter 2.

That is why the standard of proof matters so much in these cases. Under the stricter framework, an applicant has to remove doubt about a document someone else may have completed. Under the Fourth Circuit's rule, the question becomes whether the evidence, weighed fairly, makes it more likely than not that the applicant is admissible. Relevant evidence may show that the applicant did not make the claim, timely retracted it, or that citizenship did not affect the purpose or benefit sought. USCIS explains that a timely retraction must be voluntary and made before an official challenges the person’s truthfulness and before the proceeding concludes. Admitting the claim only after a challenge is not a timely retraction.

There is a narrow statutory exception when each natural or adoptive parent was a U.S. citizen, the person permanently resided in the United States before age 16, and the person reasonably believed at the time that they were a citizen. There is no general waiver of this ground in INA § 212, although Congress authorized waivers for certain adjustment categories. Special Immigrant Juvenile and registry applicants are exempt from the ground. The availability of an exception, exemption, or waiver depends on the specific case and category.

Form I-9 compliance steps for employers and HR teams

Form I-9 Section 1 is the employee’s attestation, signed under penalty of perjury. The USCIS Handbook for Employers directs that the employee complete Section 1 no later than the first day of employment. The employer reviews it but may not complete Section 1 for the employee. A preparer or translator may assist, but each must complete a separate Preparer and/or Translator Certification block in Supplement A. See the USCIS M-274 Handbook, Section 3.0.

The way Section 1 was completed can become evidence in an immigration case years later. Employers should treat onboarding procedures as an important part of I-9 compliance and workforce compliance.

HR professional points to the signature line while a new employee signs an employment form

Practical steps for employers include:

  • Do not pre-select or suggest an attestation box, and do not complete Section 1 for a new hire.
  • Use Supplement A when a preparer or translator assists.
  • Train HR, hiring managers, and staffing-agency personnel on the employee’s responsibility to complete Section 1.
  • Keep onboarding records that identify who completed each part. Use a documented process for remote or translated onboarding.
  • Do not request specific documents to verify information entered in Section 1. Unlawful document requests can create discrimination exposure under INA § 274B.
  • Treat I-9 records as potentially discoverable in immigration proceedings.

A false citizenship attestation can create a severe, potentially lasting immigration problem for an employee; it is not a benefit. HR staff cannot undo the underlying representation by editing the form later. Confirmed form errors must be handled under the Handbook’s correction procedures, but a later correction does not retroactively erase a past claim. The decision creates no new employer verification duty and does not impose a new Form I-9 or E-Verify obligation.

Steps for applicants, families, and sponsoring employers

If a green card applicant has faced a false-claim allegation, preserve the Form I-9 and any Supplement A, onboarding records, offer letter, HR correspondence, prior immigration filings, and evidence showing who completed the form. Where possible, obtain a written declaration from the person who completed it. Do not file a new application or speak with immigration officials about the issue before an immigration attorney reviews the record. Identify the federal circuit where the case will be heard.

People in removal proceedings with a pending adjustment application should ask counsel whether the Fourth Circuit standard is available, whether a remand or motion is appropriate, and how to build a preponderance-of-the-evidence record. A family’s approved Form I-130 does not cure inadmissibility. The proof standard can decide an adjustment case even when the qualifying family relationship is established.

Employers sponsoring workers should also address potential I-9 citizenship claims early. A false-claim issue can derail an employment-based adjustment application, including one supported by a work visa for foreign employees. A business immigration attorney can help employers assess the immigration implications while maintaining appropriate workforce compliance practices.

Illustration of an attorney and client reviewing documents, a checklist, and a calendar at a table

Watch for further proceedings in Nivar Santana, decisions from other circuits, possible BIA action on Matter of Bett, and any USCIS Policy Manual update addressing the ruling.

Legal information and how to get advice

This article provides general legal information, not legal advice. Immigration outcomes depend on individual facts and governing law. Reading this article does not create an attorney-client relationship.

For case-specific guidance on adjustment of status, removal proceedings, family immigration, or I-9 compliance, contact Blasingame Law LLC or review the firm’s immigration legal services. Families with a pending or denied green card application can also review the firm’s family immigration practice and schedule a consultation before the next filing or hearing.

Tags :

Share post :

Related

No Content Available

Related

No Content Available
Isabel Guevara

Isabel Guevara

Immigration Paralegal
First generation Mexican American and Colorado native. AILA Affiliated Paralegal with over 10 years of experience navigating the ever-changing world of immigration. I work to create relationships with individuals, families, and companies, streamline workflow to compile strong evidence in support of clients’ applications and petitions, and successfully lead clients to approvals. My experience includes both family-based and employment-based cases. Working through numerous government websites and filing applications both electronically and on paper. Monitoring open cases throughout each phase and communication with clients. Maintaining office efficiency. When I’m not in the office, you can find me traveling the world, eating great food, and spending time with the people I love.
Addy Blasingame-Marchitell

Addy Blasingame-Marchitell

Chief Comfort Officer (CCO)
Addy is experienced in emotional support, security, and acting door bell duty. She loves people and spreading joy, laughter, and corgi “glitter” where ever she wanders. When she is not on duty at the law firm she practices her herding skills, chasing and catching tennis balls, organizes stuff-animal tug-o-war, and plays keep away with her human and canine friends.
Amber L. Blasingame Business Immigration Lawyer Colorado Springs, Business Immigration Solutions, Family Immigration Lawyer Colorado Springs

Amber L. Blasingame

Managing Attorney

Ms. Blasingame’s practice is focused on immigration law in business, worksite compliance, family, and humanitarian matters. She has worked in immigration law since 1995 in both corporate and law firm settings, including managing the employer compliance program and immigration team in the US and Canada for one of the “Big 4” account firms’ multi-national consulting practice. She has worked with individuals and employers of all sizes, public and private, on strategies for workforce migration and compliance, family unity, and humanitarian needs, temporary and permanent. Ms. Blasingame has successfully represented clients before the US Departments of Labor, State, Justice, and Homeland Security. Ms. Blasingame has written and edited articles and presented on various topics in immigration law. She earned her JD from the University of Denver, Sturm College of Law, in 2010, where she was a senior staff editor on the Denver University Law Review, participated in the DU asylum clinic, and received a scholastic excellence award in advanced immigration law. She earned her BA in English with minors in Communication Arts and French from Allegheny College in Meadville, PA. Ms. Blasingame is a member of the American Immigration Lawyers Association (AILA), Colorado Women’s Bar Association, and the El Paso County Bar Association in Colorado.